Thank you, Aaron, for the challenge. My main problem was the shallow inward bulge of my moth’s PM line with only faint dark clouding inside, the almost straight AM line and the extended black along the basal portion of the costa. The “rather worn” argument, of course, goes both ways, and applying it to franclemonti certainly weakens my argument in favor of puncticosta. Looking now at my and BugGuide’s franclemonti photos again with respect to the criteria I list, I concede that you are right.