Identification, Images, & Information
For Insects, Spiders & Their Kin
For the United States & Canada
Clickable Guide
Moths Butterflies Flies Caterpillars Flies Dragonflies Flies Mantids Cockroaches Bees and Wasps Walkingsticks Earwigs Ants Termites Hoppers and Kin Hoppers and Kin Beetles True Bugs Fleas Grasshoppers and Kin Ticks Spiders Scorpions Centipedes Millipedes

Fall Fund Drive

FOR REVIEW: Where Do I Post It? (Identification)

BugGuide is a big place, and it's easy to wonder if anyone will ever see your image or question. Posting to the wrong place can, at best, make a bad first impression, and, at worst, mean that the people who could identify your image or answer your ID question might not see it for a long time.

This is intended to be a collection of recommended practices from our regulars and feedback from our experts on where they would prefer to see things posted. Corrections, comment, and additions are encouraged.


General:
•If you don’t have an image, post a topic in the General Discussion Forum asking about it
•If you do have an image, please don’t post a topic in the forums- that’s what ID Request is for. Posting a topic with images from other sites is a particularly bad idea- even sites designed for that like Photobucket or Flickr.

Images:
Many experts use the Recent tab to look for images to identify, so they'll see your image no matter where you post it. There are also some experts and other editors who look through ID Request from time to time and move things where they belong. That means ID Request is always a safe bet.
It's true that some experts concentrate on the parts of the guide that they know most about, so there are times it's better to post images there instead of ID Request. Posting to the wrong places in the guide, though, can hide your image from those experts.

Three Simple Rules:

1.   When in doubt- post it to ID Request

2.   Without breaking the next rule, post things to the lowest (most specific) level where you know it belongs (example: if you’re not sure whether it’s a grasshopper or a cricket, post it to Orthoptera, the lowest level that contains both).

3.   Avoid in-between levels. Order, Family, Genus and Species generally get the most attention. There are exceptions (see below), but otherwise, stick to those four.

Exceptions To Order/Family/Genus/Species rule:

Arachnids:
Best posted to order if you don’t know the family, but if you’re not certain of the order, just post it to ID Request. Be careful, though: if it doesn’t have a tail with a stinger on the end, it’s not a scorpion. Also be careful about spiders: true spiders have the body divided into two parts, while there are harvestmen, mites and ticks that have only one. When in doubt- post to ID Request.

Other non-insect Arthropods:
Best posted to class. If you’re not sure what class it is- post it to ID Request.

Insects:

Damselflies:
Suborder Zygoptera

Dragonflies (If you know it’s not a damselfly):
Suborder Anisoptera

Mantids:
Now are in their own order Mantodea- but you still need to make sure it’s not a Mantidfly or Water Scorpion.

Cockroaches:
Now are in their own order Blattodea- but it now includes Termites- Epifamily Isoptera You can post termites there, but be careful not to mistake Webspinners (Order Embiidina) for termites.

True bugs:
Suborder Heteroptera

Beetles:
Make sure you know the difference between beetles and true bugs before you post to Order Coleoptera. Otherwise- post to ID Request.

Order Lepidoptera:
Caterpillars should go to:
the order page or to ID Request. "Caterpillars" that have only the six legs in front, no legs at all, or too many legs, may be beetle, fly or sawfly larvae. When in doubt, post to ID Request.

Adults should go to:
Butterflies (clubbed antennae)- Papilionoidea
Moths (antennae with no clubs or hooks on the end)- Moths
   If the antennae are very long and straight, make sure it’s not a Caddisfly (or just post it to ID Request).
Skippers (antennae with hooks on the end)- Family Hesperiidae
If this seems too complicated- post to Lepidoptera, or to ID Request.

Bees, wasps, ants, etc.:
There are so many flies, beetles, moths and other insects that try so hard to pass themselves off as bees and wasps, even experts get fooled sometimes. There are characteristics of the eyes, antennae, wings and abdomen that can be used to tell these apart, but until you know those well, it's best to post anything that looks like a bee or a wasp to ID Request. The same can be said of ants.

If you do have a pretty good idea that you're dealing with the real thing- and not a look-alike- bees should go to Anthophila, regular wasps should go to Aculeata, and ants should go to Formicidae (just be careful that you don't have a velvet ant). If it has a narrow waist and an ovipositor, post it to parasitic Apocrita. Otherwise, Hymenoptera or ID Request.

 
How I see it.
I consider the target for this to be those who are just reaching the level where they could post a few things to the guide. Those who know family/genus/etc don't need most of this (though rule #3 is ignored too often even by some near-expert editors).

Aside from the stated purpose of cutting down on the workload of no-brainer moves by editors, my main goal is to minimize errors caused by people not knowing what they don't know. I figure some people are going to post to the guide no matter what, so I want them to know how to avoid the most common rookie errors.

 
Then . . .
will there be one set of guidelines for people who know what they're doing and another set for the rest of us?

 
See Rule #1 of Chuck's article...
"When in doubt -- post it to ID Request."

No need to make yourself nuts over this issue. (*smile*) Do your best to try and identify your critter to a basic category, and if you're not sure -- see Rule #1.

 
please post aculeates to
ID request

 
*
thank you for the input, Dr. Ascher

 
So -
what do we do when there aren't any comments on bee images in the back of ID request? Dr. Ascher is very kind to comment on as many bee images as he does, but some series inevitably end up sitting in ID Request for a long time. Can we move those to Anthophila after a couple of months?

One current example here:

 
Handling Aculeata images: An update
Those who take turns cleaning up the ID Request know that bee and wasp images tend to accumulate ‘at the bottom’ –- presumably, because many editors, myself including, take too literally Dr Ascher’s 6.vii.2009 comment above (“please post aculeates to ID request”).
Given the obvious problem this verbatim interpretation has caused, I asked Dr Ascher to elaborate his position. His response is summarized below, as applicable to our ID Request cleaning task.
=============
Dr Ascher routinely checks the Hymenoptera, Aculeates, Bees, etc., pages, so it’s OK to post there or move images out of ID Request to these guide pages. He wanted images in ID Request for no longer than 2 days, after which time they should be moved to the lowest certainly applicable taxon pages. (If a bee, to Bees; if an unknown vespid, to Vespidae; if a Polistes, to Polistes page, etc.)
=============
Chuck, would you please update the recommendations accordingly?

 
Updated...
but I have a feeling it will need some tweaking and tuning to get it right...

 
much appreciated
i'm confident you'll refine the language to perfection

 
Thanks for clarifying this
Some time ago I posted my opinion that images should remain in ID Request long enough to be seen (at least 1 and perhaps 2 full days), but after that I prefer for them to be moved to guide pages as appropriate.

first page
previous page
1 2
 
 
Comment viewing options
Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.