Identification, Images, & Information
For Insects, Spiders & Their Kin
For the United States & Canada
Clickable Guide
Moths Butterflies Flies Caterpillars Flies Dragonflies Flies Mantids Cockroaches Bees and Wasps Walkingsticks Earwigs Ants Termites Hoppers and Kin Hoppers and Kin Beetles True Bugs Fleas Grasshoppers and Kin Ticks Spiders Scorpions Centipedes Millipedes

Calendar

TaxonomyBrowseInfoImagesLinksBooksData
Photo#689344
Snipe Fly - Symphoromyia sackeni - female

Snipe Fly - Symphoromyia sackeni - Female
About a mile east of the crest on Nascimiento Rd, Santa Lucia Mountains, Los Padres National Forest, Monterey County, California, USA
June 16, 2011
Initially, I thought this was some sort of deer fly...from its gestalt (especially that "beak") and behavior (flew inside the car, then buzzed loudly at the window, etc.). Indeed, it turns out it is a biter (or more accurately, a "slash & lapper")...but the eyes and antenna didn't look right for a deer fly.

My hesitations were validated when it keyed unambiguously to family Rhagionidae, genus Symphoromyia in MND(1), Cole(2), and Curran(3). This is a female, from the well-separated eyes and conspicuously large blood-feeding mouthparts. (Males are holoptic(4) and do not feed on blood.) Some salient characters for the ID's to family and genus: empodia pulvilliform (see right foreleg); 1st antennomere (or 3rd segment...after scape and pedicel) concave below the dorsally attached arista (see 2nd photo in series); clypeus conspicuous, convex; anal lobe and alula well-developed; hind tibia with 1 terminal spur (note that it looks like there are two tibial spurs visible through the (R5 cell of the) right wing in the photo above, but that's because the fly was rubbing its two hind-legs together! :-)

Using the key for females on pg. 118 of Aldrich's 1915 "The dipterous genus Symphoromyia in North America" (PDF here), this specimen keys almost immediately to species S. sackeni as follows:

1a. Third joint of antenna concave at apex, below the arista....2
1b. Third joint convex as usual...................................5
2a. Abdomen yellow in ground color( Washington; California)...sackeni, new species
2b. Abdomen black..............3 (key continues from here...)

The description of the female of S. sackeni on pg 140 of Aldrich (1915) fits my specimen very well, and it occurs in CA. Aldrich's key treated females for 17 of the 22 species he covered. Fifty-four years later, Cole(2) discussed the genus and indicated no new taxa up to then (though one species was synonymized, and others described for sexes missing in Aldrich's work). Regarding S. sackeni, Cole wrote: "abdomen wholly yellow in the female, yellow on the sides in the slender, dark male, the species being unique in this coloration". This statement seems to strongly reinforce a putative ID of S. sackeni here. However, the "uniqueness" Cole had in mind may have referred to both the female and male colorations, taken together...in which case the reinforcement is weaker.

If the taxonomy in the genus Symphoromyia had stayed static since 1969, I may have made a guide page for S. sackeni and placed these images there. But as might be expected, more species have been described since then. The excellent 2004 worldwide revision of rhagionid genera by Kerr(4) lists 30 species with types in the USA (29 of which appear on the ITIS Symphoromyia page). The species S. sackeni is on this list, so it hasn't been buried in synonymy. But with the addition of 9 more species, the wholly yellow female that Cole saw fit to remark on may no longer be unique...and this could now be something else.

Any comments, corrections, or confirmations here would be much appreciated.

Images of this individual: tag all
Snipe Fly - Symphoromyia sackeni - female Snipe Fly - Symphoromyia sackeni - female

Moved

Sounds good to me
Four of the new species since Aldrich 1915 are closely related to S. pachyceras (Turner & Chillcott, 1973) so they can probably be excluded. Might be worth sending an email to Dr. Kerr at CDFA for his opinion.

 
Good Points, Brad
Makes sense from the title of their paper:

Turner, W. J. & J. G. Chillcott (1973). Four new species of the Symphoromyia pachyceras complex from California (Diptera: Rhagionidae). Pan-Pacific Entomol., 49: 5-20.

I haven't seen that paper, and am not familiar with S. pachyceras (perhaps you are), but according to the key in Aldrich (1915), females of S. pachyceras have:

1) "3rd joint of antenna convex as usual";
2) "knob of halter infuscated"; and
3) overall color much darker than "pale plumbeous" (where "plumbeous" means "the blue-grey of lead"...from the wonderful glossary of "words referring to color" in Cole(1)).

And Aldrich's description of female S. pachyceras (on pg. 134) indicates that most the dorsum of the abdomen is black or brown pollinose...but he ends with "Abdomen tapering, cinereous, dark above, the pile almost all yellow." The pile almost all yellow part gives me some pause, but it does seem likely those four species can probably be excluded.

That would leave just 5 species unaccounted for :-). I wonder where they were published? I couldn't find an obvious reference by searching the bibliography in Kerr(2).

At any rate, I'll try to contact Dr. Kerr, as you wisely suggest. Thanks for your interest and comments.

 
Dr. Kerr responds...
"It is likely that you are correct to refer to this fly as S. sackeni, although any species-level determination of this group must be taken with a grain of salt. Alpha-taxonomic work on this group is still needed…"

Comment viewing options
Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.